Roo's Verdict
Top picks ranked by relevance and ratings.
We compared thousands of Maybelline black eyeshadows from $4 to $16 across Amazon, Walmart, and Target. The MAYBELLINE Color Tattoo Eye Shadow Stix 1ct ($9.73 at Amazon) is our best value pick at 4.4 stars with 3,300+ reviews — offering long-lasting wear and vibrant color.
🏆 Best Value
The MAYBELLINE Color Tattoo Eye Shadow Stix 1ct ($9.73 at Amazon) is our best value pick at 4.4 stars with 3,300+ reviews. It provides up to 24 hours of wear and is easy to apply, making it a reliable choice for everyday use.
3 stores
compared in real time
36+ products
tracked for this search
285% price gap
$4.26 – $16.40 range
Updated Apr 30, 2026
prices verified today
How we ranked Maybelline Black Eyeshadow: Shopperoo compared 36+ options across 3 stores (Amazon, Target, Walmart) and scored each on price , star rating, review volume, and availability. The cheapest option is $4.26 at Amazon — 285% less than the highest-priced equivalent. Roo's best value pick is "MAYBELLINE Color Tattoo Eye Shadow Stix 1ct" at Amazon for $9.73 (4.4 ★ from 3.3K reviews). Rankings are updated in real time and are not influenced by retailer fees or sponsored placements.
Get Today's Best Price
We check 10+ retailers so you don't have to.
Quick Comparison: Top Picks
Best Value
MAYBELLINE Color Tattoo Eye Shadow Stix 1ct
$9.73 at Amazon
- ✓4.4 stars with 3,300+ reviews for reliable performance
- ✓Long-lasting wear for up to 24 hours
Budget
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancer Eyeshadow 0.09oz
$4.26 at Amazon
What to Look For in Maybelline Black Eyeshadow
- Color payoff: Look for eyeshadows that deliver vibrant color with minimal application.
- Longevity: Choose products that promise long wear to avoid touch-ups throughout the day.
- Application method: Consider whether you prefer cream, powder, or stick formulas for ease of use.
How Shopperoo Compares Products
Shopperoo's AI scans live pricing from Amazon, Walmart, Target, Kroger, and other major retailers, then ranks products by balancing price, ratings, review count, and availability. Our best value pick isn't just the cheapest — it's the product with the best combination of low price and high customer satisfaction. Learn more about our methodology
Get Today's Best Price
We check 10+ retailers so you don't have to.
FAQ: Maybelline Black Eyeshadow
Where is Maybelline Black Eyeshadow cheapest right now?
The budget Maybelline Black Eyeshadow is $4.26 at Amazon ($47.33/count) — "COVERGIRL Eye Enhancer Eyeshadow 0.09oz". The most expensive is $16.40 at Amazon ($182.22/count) — a 285% price gap for comparable products. Price gaps this wide typically reflect differences in pack size, bundle inclusions, or retailer promotional cycles. Shopperoo checks 3 stores in real time so this reflects today's live pricing as of Apr 30, 2026.
What's the best value Maybelline Black Eyeshadow?
Roo's best value pick is "MAYBELLINE Color Tattoo Eye Shadow Stix 1ct" at Amazon for $9.73 - it scores best on price ($9.73/count), rating (4.4★ from 3.3K reviews) and availability.
Which stores have Maybelline Black Eyeshadow?
Shopperoo found Maybelline Black Eyeshadow in stock at all 3 stores we track: Amazon, Target, Walmart. Amazon carries the widest selection, followed by Target. Store availability and pricing are checked in real time — if a store sells out or changes its price, Shopperoo updates within hours. Prices last verified Apr 30, 2026.
How does Shopperoo rank Maybelline Black Eyeshadow?
Shopperoo pulls live product data from 3 retailers and scores each Maybelline Black Eyeshadow on four factors: price per unit, star rating, number of verified reviews, and real-time stock availability. Products are grouped into three lists — Best Value, Top Rated, and Lowest Price — so shoppers can choose based on their priorities. No retailer pays to appear in these rankings; placement is determined solely by the score.
How much can I save on Maybelline Black Eyeshadow?
Choosing Shopperoo's best-value pick saves $7 compared to Amazon's default top result. Amazon's algorithm surfaces sponsored and Prime-eligible products first, which aren't always the best price. The full price spread across all 3 stores is 285% — $12.14/count between the cheapest and most expensive comparable option. Shopperoo's rankings are not influenced by affiliate fees or sponsored placements.